Keenan graduated from Wabash College with a bachelor's degree in economics. He and his wife, Beth, have two sons, Caden and Bo. They reside in the Meridian Kessler area of Indianapolis. In addition to spending time with his family and friends, Keenan loves to be outdoors.

The most common and biggest barrier to clients living their most fulfilling life is a misunderstanding of their own financial capacity. Keenan has dedicated his career to helping clients gain clarity and perspective around what is possible and challenging them to intentionally live their best life.

He makes complex financial topics simple and helps clients achieve the ultimate peace of mind that comes when they fully understand how/why their plan will work. Keenan is passionate about helping you uncover your vision and providing the directions to get you there. He works to help you eliminate unnecessary financial anxiety and gain the confidence to spend more of your life on what matters most.

CFP® - CERTIFIED FINANCIAL PLANNER™ designation
ChFC® - Chartered Financial Consultant designation
CLU® - Chartered Life Underwriter designation
CPWA® - Certified Private Wealth Advisor

Scott McDonald is a seasoned financial advisor who brings a wealth of experience to the Verity team. For over 30 years, Scott has helped families, charities, and businesses focus, build, and execute financial plans to achieve their most ambitious goals. He joined Northwestern Mutual in 1989, after completing an internship and graduating from Indiana University-Purdue University Indianapolis with a bachelor’s degree in business.

Growing up on a farm in central Iowa, hard work and midwestern values are deeply rooted in Scott. He and his wife, Karen, have four children: Paul (Brit), Madeline, Blake, and Remy. They reside in the Williams Creek area of Indianapolis.

The McDonald family enjoys spending time with family and friends and being outdoors at every opportunity. Scott and his family are active members of Faith Church on the northside of Indianapolis, where Scott is currently serving as a Deacon. Scott has held many roles in the Boy Scouts of America over the years. He also is regularly active on the Heritage Christian School campus, where all four of his children have attended.

Scott has his FINRA Series 6, 63 and SIE registrations.

Michael Nicolai brings 16 years of financial services experience to the team. He assists in the development and implementation of clients’ financial plans and provides service on small business retirement plans.

Michael earned an MBA from Purdue University’s Krannert School of Management and an accounting degree from Indiana Wesleyan University. The next leg of his academic journey includes a master’s in accounting from Indiana University’s Kelley School of Business in Indianapolis.

Michael is married to Amber, and they have three children: Allison, Claire, and Liam. Currently residing near Pendleton, Ind., he enjoys making memories with family traveling and being outdoors.

Haydon’s drive to help others financially and work as part of a successful team were key factors in joining Verity. As a Financial Planning Analyst, he creates and analyzes financial plans for our clients, whilst recommending future strategies. Each plan is tailored to the clients’ individual goals and needs, with extensive thought put towards the best actions for their financial future.

An Australian native, Haydon was born and raised in Melbourne before moving to the US in 2017. He is the oldest of 4 children and remains in regular contact with his siblings, Breanna, Nick, and Olivia, despite living across the globe. Haydon completed his studies at Indiana University, where he was a member of the IU Football Team and the team’s leadership group.

Karen joined the Verity Team in 2022. As Verity’s Marketing Coordinator, Karen coordinates all the marketing activities and initiatives of Verity. Her background includes Marketing Director and Project Manager in the retail and fundraising software sector.

Karen earned a bachelor's degree from Earlham College majoring in Management and French and a master's in business administration from the University of Minnesota Carlson School of Management with a concentration in Marketing. Outside of the office, Karen loves spending time with her husband Scott and their four children and daughter in law, Paul (Brit), Madeline, Blake, and Remy. She loves being with friends and anything that takes place outdoors (especially the beach). Karen enjoys hiking, running, reading, and traveling anywhere new. She is active in her church and loves entertaining friends and family in her home.